Ideas that Impact
  • Ideas that Impact
  • SE101: Socent

Hacking Attribution: Thought Contributors* [1 of 3]

3/3/2012

2 Comments

 
                                                             How do we value collectively created knowledge? [FULL]
     Hacking Academia [2 of 3]
                                                                                                                                                                     Hacking Working Together  [3 of 3]
                                                                                                                                                                               
On this month's blogging sprint*, I am experimenting with a new strategy that plays with an idea we explored in the Macroscope Labs project.  On each post, I include a Thought Contributors** an acknowledgment that lists people with whom I have discussed this idea as it was evolving.  

*Thought Contributors: These ideas have been percolating and evolved in conversations with many people.  I am prototyping a new method of attributing collectively crafted ideas.  In academia, whoever writes the grant or publishes the paper gets "credit" but in reality the breakthrough idea may come from a colleague in the work-in-progress phase or comments on a draft.  It's time that we begin to develop better systems that reflect and honor the collective participation in the formulation of ideas. Those I mention here are people who have informed, influenced and participated in the evolution of ideas herein.  I am grateful for their perspectives which have helped to enhance my thinking on these issues. I'll be curious for feedback whether that works and seems sufficient, insufficient, confusing, overwhelming.  

How one chooses to see the source of ideas and how one chooses to attribute will be subjective. Some of the justifications for less/no** attribution: many ideas are emerging at the same time. There are no new ideas.  With information everywhere it is nearly impossible to keep track of all the sources of input and influence. We are all part of a global brain, there is no "I".  While I am not attached to the ideas that I have,  I endeavor to practice attribution holistically and rigorously (partially attributed to residual side effect of legal training) though mostly due to my aim that any recognition flows back to original sources and influencers as much as possible; I see attribution as essential to integrity in a system because it honors the depth and breadth of others' contributions to the value that I create.  

What do you do to acknowledge the influencers in your work?  

What have you seen others do that inspired you? 



*Thought Contributors:  Edward Harran, Jay Standish, Jerry Michaelski, Arthur Brock , Eric Harris Braun, pls ping me if I missed you!  This topic jumped to the front of the loopback queue due to a tag on a FB thread that semi-relates to this topic. 

**modified 3.7.2012 from less rigorous to less/no to better reflect intended meaning which was not a judgment rather the degree/amount of references to sources.

***March blogging sprint: #b03 Day 4: I am participating in a pledge to blog daily during March initiated by Steve Hopkins of the Squiggly Line blog. Follow the daily work of all participants on twitter under #b03 
2 Comments
Jean Russell link
7/3/2012 04:50:01 am

I wonder if the attribution in a world that has moved beyond the "I" would be necessary? Is this step of revealing the cascading flows of attribution part of a process of demystifying how work and ideas happens... and the next phase will respond to that by not having an "author" nor "attribution" because all things are seen as arising from networks and the collective consciousness?

Reply
Kate
12/3/2012 03:24:44 am

Thanks for your thoughts Jean.

Yes, the idea, perhaps not well expressed, is to reveal the many people who contribute to the evolution of an idea. The aim is to address a concern about blogs as contributing to the culture of "I" in a similar way that a recent Atlantic Monthly article critiques TED talks: http://ow.ly/9vTKU ↬ Pritha Raysicar (@pritharaysicar)

There are many approaches on how to attribute. Some in the avant garde of the blogosphere may view their ideas as emerging from collective consciousness so they include no attribution and/or a network may write without authors as networked knowledge (the format for most major consultancy reports). This is an area for plurality; hopefully, with transparency, writers can develop discipline/community appropriate conventions that can coexist without rebuke or recrimination.

This blog's method aims to honor the many influencers of ideas by following Charles Eames: "To be realistic one must always admit the influence of those who have gone before." ᔥ The Curator's Code: www.curatorscode.org, which provides tools and a convention for attribution when curating information. I will endeavor to use these conventions as well. ↬ Pritha Raysicar (@pritharaysicar)

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    part of Kate's Mural

    idea incubator & 
    prototype lab 
     . . . architecting hope . . .  


    Featured
    Guest Posts
    101
    21st Century Career
    Changemakers
    Creative
    Design
    Ethics
    Learning
    Leadership
    Life Lessons
    Social Impact

    Sectors
    Aging
    Education
    Health
    Macroscope
    Social Enterprise

    Themes
    Wildflower (thoughts)
    Idea (seeds)
    Prototype (experiments)

    Failures
    Fun
    Future/Innovation

    About this blog
    About Kate
    View my profile on LinkedIn
    Picture
    All writing licensed by
    Kate Michi Ettinger and guest contributors under a
    Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    April 2016
    March 2015
    January 2015
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    November 2012
    August 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    March 2011
    September 2010
    August 2010
    June 2010
    November 2009
    October 2009
    July 2008
    May 2008
    April 2008
    March 2008
    February 2008
    October 2007
    July 2007
    June 2007